CMJ Editorial Review Form

Manuscript No:*

Title of the paper:*

Please provide a competing interests statement:

Corresponding Author*

Corresponding Author Email address*

PLEASE TICK APPROPRIATE RESPONSES BELOW
WRITE N/A TO ANY CATEGORIES THAT MAY NOT APPLY

1. Is there an ethical approval statement?*

2. Does the author disclose financial conflicts of interest? *

3. Is there a funding statement?*

4. Have the authors listed the individual author contributions?*

Confidential Comments to the Chief Editor
If you have comments regarding the paper to the Editor that you do NOT want to be passed on to the authors, please use the space below:

Editorial Comments*

Editorial Comments for the Authors
Please review the comments provided by the peer reviewers and provide your own comments to the authors. A final decision should be made based on the editorial and peer reviewer comments.
The decision, editorial comments and peer reviewers comments will then be sent to the authors.

Editorial Comments to Authors*

Final Recommendation:*

Accept with minor revisions

Reconsider after extensive revision

Reject

Date*

This field should be left blank

Article Categories

Recent Posts